Pages

Saturday, January 5, 2013

Detective Conan vs. Kindaichi Case Files(名探偵コナン vs. 金田一少年の事件簿)



Hello, guys! This is The Awesome me again, Sakata Hiroki! :D

And so… Now I’ll tell you about two of the most popular detective comics, Conan and Kindaichi! Maybe you all already know about these two mystery comics, or at least one of them, since they’re pretty popular… Well. I, honestly, really, really love these two. Why? Because they have they own uniqueness and awesomeness. Maybe it’s also because I really enjoy mystery comics and novels very much… It depends, though. Anyway, they are all great comics to read, and I recommend the two of them! >w<



Here’s my rating (0-10) for those two comics, and remember, this is just what I think, so don’t judge them directly. It depends on you, like I said. I just want to give you some references, but don’t believe me straight away. You’re talking about weird girl, after all XD








Let’s see! (>w<)/

1.       Storyline (Plot)
Conan : 9/10, Kindaichi : 8/10




Why I give better score for Conan? Well, because, Conan has a better plot (about the Black Organization, particularly, I love that plot!), after all. But it doesn’t mean Kindaichi has bad plot, no, I just prefer Conan’s. Maybe you like Kindaichi’s more, that’s just my opinion :D

2.       Art
Conan : 9.5/10, Kindaichi : 8/10



I like Gosho Aoyama-sensei’s drawing style, personally :D

3.       Case, tricks, etc.
Conan : 8/10, Kindaichi : 9.5/10



Here it comes. I love the cases in Kindaichi! The tricks are harder to guess than Conan’s (for me, of course), and I just love how they kill the victim… Ah, sorry, I like gore, so… XD

Anyway, for me, all Amagi-sensei’s works are really awesome! Not only Kindaichi, but also Detective Academy Q (I’ll explain about that later! >w<), and I simply love them very much :D

4.       Characters
Conan : 9/10, Kindaichi : 9/10


Now there’s a tie! In one side, the characters in Conan are perfect (see Shinichi, Heiji, Kaitou Kid, Yuusaku, etc.), know everything, very smart, and… Well yeah handsome. Hey, we’re talking about the guys here! I’m not really concerned about the girls, after all… Anyway, this “perfectness” is what makes Conan has strong characters, and not to mention, their own uniqueness XD





In other hand, Kindaichi, the main character, is what you call… Stupid? Lazy? Yeah, he always gets bad scores at school (not to mention he often does weird and perverted things)… And he doesn’t know complicated things (like the one with sodium lamp (lampu natrium tegangan rendah)… How do you translate it in English, anyway? For Kindaichi, I just read the translated (Indonesian) version, and watch the Indonesian-dubbed anime long, looong time ago, after all)… But strangely, he can solve so many difficult cases! And the fact that he’s Kindaichi Kosuke’s grandson, that’s really unique, for me! His rival, Akechi Kengo, is what you call a great policeman. Smart, yes! Handsome, yes!! And he wears glasses, and, and… *ignore this* >///<




Anyway… They’re very good as team, really! The lazy Kindaichi and the perfect Akechi, they’re some of Kindaichi’s overall great characters X3


Well, I guess that's it! Now, what do you think? Wanna read them? :D
I highly recomend both of them! >w<

See you in the next post! XD

No comments:

Post a Comment